10 Effective School Improvement Ideas for Education Leaders
School improvement is rarely about finding one big idea that changes everything overnight. More often, it comes from making informed decisions, getting the basics right and helping people across the school work towards a shared purpose.
For headteachers, senior leaders and governors, the challenge is finding the time and space to identify what needs to improve, decide what will make the biggest difference and make sure that plans lead to meaningful change for pupils.
There is no shortage of initiatives, frameworks and advice available to schools. The difficult part is knowing which actions will have the greatest impact in your particular setting.
Effective school improvement starts with understanding your school, being honest about what the evidence tells you and turning that understanding into a manageable plan.
Here are ten practical school improvement ideas education leaders can use to strengthen provision, support staff and make progress that lasts.
1. Focus on the priorities that will make the biggest difference
One of the most common challenges in school improvement is trying to do too much at once.
A school might identify concerns around attendance, behaviour, curriculum, teaching, assessment, inclusion and outcomes. Each area matters, but attempting to address everything simultaneously can leave staff stretched and progress difficult to measure.
Start by asking three questions:
- What is currently working well?
- Where is the greatest gap between what we want for pupils and what they experience?
- Which improvement would make the biggest difference if we addressed it successfully?
Use these questions to identify a small number of meaningful priorities.
For example, if pupils are struggling to retain knowledge, the answer might not be to introduce several new teaching initiatives. It may be more effective to focus on how curriculum content is sequenced, how teachers revisit previous learning and how leaders evaluate whether pupils remember what they have been taught.
In our experience, effective school improvement starts with focus.
Review your current school development plan. Can every priority be clearly justified by evidence? Are there initiatives that could be paused, combined or removed to give staff more time to focus on the work that matters most?
A focused plan gives leaders a clearer direction and staff a better understanding of what they are working towards. Our guide on how to prioritise the areas that will make the biggest difference explores this in more detail.
Are you focusing on the right priorities?
If your school has several competing priorities, an independent perspective can help you step back, review the evidence and identify where your efforts could make the greatest difference.
2. Make your school self-evaluation evidence-led
School leaders develop a detailed understanding of their setting over time. However, being close to the day-to-day running of a school can make it difficult to see every strength, weakness or inconsistency objectively.
Effective self-evaluation brings together different sources of evidence rather than relying on one person’s opinion or a single set of results. Our guide to developing an effective school self-evaluation sets out a practical process.
This might include:
- Pupil progress and attainment information.
- Attendance, behaviour and exclusion patterns.
- Lesson visits and learning walks.
- Work in pupils’ books and their understanding of what they are learning.
- Pupil, parent and staff feedback.
- Information about vulnerable pupils and groups who may need additional support.
- The effectiveness of previous improvement actions.
The important point is to look for patterns and test assumptions.
For example, strong overall attendance figures may conceal persistent absence among a particular group of pupils. Positive feedback from staff may sit alongside concerns about workload or the consistency of teaching across different departments.
Neither finding automatically tells the whole story. Together, however, they can help leaders ask better questions.
In our experience, good self-evaluation starts with asking the right questions.
Choose one current improvement priority and bring together at least three different sources of evidence. What do they tell you collectively? Where are there gaps in your understanding?
An independent perspective can also help leaders test their judgements. Jarvis Education’s School Improvement Partner service explains how external challenge can support self-evaluation, strengthen decision-making and help schools identify realistic next steps.
Would a fresh pair of eyes help?
School leaders know their schools well, but an external perspective can help test assumptions, explore the evidence and bring greater clarity to self-evaluation. Find out how a School Improvement Partner can support your school.
3. Make teaching and learning a consistent focus
The quality of teaching and learning has a significant influence on pupils’ experiences at school. Yet even when individual teachers are highly effective, pupils may experience differences in expectations, teaching approaches and curriculum delivery across a school.
School improvement should help leaders understand what pupils experience in different classrooms and identify where greater consistency would be beneficial.
This does not mean requiring every teacher to teach in exactly the same way. Professional judgement matters, and different pupils and subjects may need different approaches.
Instead, leaders should establish a shared understanding of effective teaching in their context.
Consider:
- How clearly is new knowledge explained?
- Are lessons building on what pupils already know?
- How do teachers check whether pupils have understood?
- Are misconceptions identified and addressed?
- Are pupils appropriately challenged?
- How effectively are teaching approaches adapted for pupils with SEND or other additional needs?
- Do pupils remember and apply what they have learned?
Use lesson visits, work scrutiny, pupil discussions and professional dialogue to explore these questions.
In our experience, small, focused changes can make a real difference.
Identify one aspect of teaching that would benefit from greater consistency. Agree what effective practice looks like, give staff opportunities to develop it and revisit the evidence to see whether practice is improving.
Improvement is more likely to become embedded when staff understand the purpose behind a change and have the support to put it into practice.
Turn your findings into meaningful improvement
Understanding what happens in classrooms is only the starting point. The next step is deciding what the evidence tells you, where support is needed and how you will evaluate progress.
Explore how Jarvis Education supports school improvement
4. Turn your school development plan into a working document
A school development plan should do more than record what the school intends to improve. It should help leaders make decisions, allocate resources and evaluate progress throughout the year. For a step-by-step approach, read how to write a school improvement plan that leads to real change.
A lengthy plan with numerous actions can create activity without necessarily creating impact. The most useful plans make the connection between the identified problem, the action being taken and the difference expected for pupils.
For each priority, make sure you can explain:
- The issue: What does the evidence tell you needs to improve?
- The intended outcome: What should be different for pupils or staff?
- The actions: What will the school do to bring about that change?
- The responsibility: Who will lead the work and who else needs to be involved?
- The timescale: When should key actions and milestones be completed?
- The evidence of impact: How will you know whether the actions are working?
Avoid measuring success solely by whether an activity has happened.
For example, completing staff training is an action. A more meaningful evaluation considers whether staff have changed their practice and whether pupils are benefiting as a result.
In our experience, meaningful improvement comes from understanding the difference we want to make.
Take one priority from your current plan and rewrite its success measures. Move beyond statements such as “training completed” or “policy updated” and describe the change you expect to see.
If your school needs help validating its priorities and strengthening its planning, the Essentials School Improvement Partner package provides focused external support across the academic year.
Does your school development plan lead to impact?
A strong plan should make it clear what needs to change, why it matters and how you will know whether your actions are working. If you would value support in reviewing your priorities, explore the Essentials School Improvement Partner package.
5. Give middle leaders the support to lead improvement
School improvement cannot sit entirely with the headteacher or senior leadership team. Middle leaders play an important role in translating whole-school priorities into the daily experiences of pupils.
However, subject and phase leaders may be expected to manage teams, evaluate curriculum quality, monitor outcomes and lead change alongside significant teaching and operational responsibilities.
They need more than a list of actions to complete.
Effective support includes clear expectations, time to evaluate their areas, access to relevant information and opportunities to develop their leadership skills.
Senior leaders can help by:
- Making sure middle leaders understand whole-school priorities.
- Agreeing clear responsibilities and realistic expectations.
- Providing opportunities to discuss evidence and challenge assumptions.
- Supporting leaders to identify the right improvement actions.
- Reviewing progress through purposeful professional conversations.
- Recognising effective practice and sharing learning between teams.
In our experience, strong school improvement depends on developing leadership at every level.
Ask each middle leader to identify one strength, one area for improvement and the evidence supporting each judgement. Use the discussion to agree the next steps and the support they need.
This approach helps build leadership capacity across the school, rather than creating a system where every decision depends on a small number of senior leaders.
Give your leaders the support to succeed
Middle leaders have an important role in turning school priorities into everyday practice. The right support can help them build confidence, strengthen their evaluations and lead improvement more effectively.
Discover the Standard School Improvement Partner package
6. Use pupil voice to understand their experiences
Data can tell you a great deal about a school, but it cannot always explain why pupils experience school in the way they do.
Pupil voice can help leaders understand how pupils feel about learning, relationships, behaviour, belonging and the support available to them.
The most useful conversations go beyond asking pupils whether they enjoy school.
Depending on the issue being explored, leaders might ask:
- What helps you learn well in lessons?
- What do you do when you do not understand something?
- Do you know where to go for help?
- Do you feel safe and listened to?
- What makes attending school difficult?
- Do you feel that adults understand what you need?
The questions should be appropriate for pupils’ ages, communication needs and circumstances. Some pupils may feel more comfortable sharing their views in small groups, through written responses or with a trusted adult.
Leaders should also be clear about how feedback will be used. Asking for pupils’ views and then taking no action can undermine trust.
In our experience, listening to pupils can help leaders see their school from a different perspective.
Choose a current improvement priority and gather feedback from a representative group of pupils. Compare what they tell you with the evidence already available. What might you need to investigate further?
Pupil voice is most valuable when it informs decisions and helps leaders understand the impact of changes, rather than becoming a one-off consultation exercise.
Are you seeing the whole picture?
Pupil feedback can reveal things that attainment and attendance figures alone may not show. Combining different sources of evidence can help leaders make more informed decisions about the changes that matter.
7. Make inclusion part of every improvement priority
Inclusion should not be treated as a separate initiative that sits alongside the school’s main improvement work.
Whether leaders are considering curriculum, teaching, attendance, behaviour or personal development, they need to understand whether different groups of pupils are benefiting from the provision available to them.
Look beyond whole-school averages. Consider whether pupils with SEND, disadvantaged pupils, pupils with English as an additional language and other groups with specific needs are experiencing barriers to learning or participation.
Questions worth exploring include:
- Are pupils receiving the support identified for them?
- Do teaching approaches enable different pupils to access the curriculum?
- Are attendance and behaviour patterns different for particular groups?
- Do pupils feel they belong and are listened to?
- Are reasonable adjustments understood and implemented consistently?
- How do leaders know whether additional support is making a difference?
Avoid assuming that the existence of a policy or intervention demonstrates its effectiveness. Leaders need to understand what happens in practice and whether pupils benefit.
In our experience, effective school improvement considers the needs of every pupil.
For each school improvement priority, identify which groups of pupils may be affected. Consider what additional evidence you need to evaluate their experiences and progress.
Making inclusion part of everyday decision-making helps ensure that school improvement is focused on the needs of all pupils, not simply the overall picture.
8. Invest in staff development that changes practice
Professional development can play an important role in improving teaching, leadership and pupil outcomes. However, the impact depends on what happens after the training session ends.
A single INSET day may introduce a useful idea, but staff need opportunities to understand it, practise it, discuss challenges and evaluate its effectiveness.
A more sustained approach could include:
- Identifying development needs from school evidence.
- Agreeing a clear focus for professional learning.
- Providing practical training and examples.
- Creating opportunities for staff to share practice.
- Supporting colleagues to try new approaches.
- Revisiting the focus through coaching, professional dialogue or lesson visits.
- Evaluating changes in practice and their effect on pupils.
It is also important to consider workload. Introducing several new approaches at once can make it harder for staff to apply any of them consistently.
In our experience, professional development is most effective when it leads to meaningful changes in practice.
Choose one staff development priority that links directly to your school improvement plan. Agree what staff should understand or do differently, how they will be supported and when you will review the impact.
Professional development is more likely to contribute to lasting improvement when it is connected to a clear need and supported over time.
Make professional development count
Training is most valuable when it leads to changes in practice and better experiences for pupils. Taking time to evaluate the impact of staff development can help leaders understand what is working well, where further support may be needed and how professional learning can contribute to school improvement.
Explore Jarvis Education’s Training & Professional Development to find out how tailored training can support your school’s priorities and help staff put learning into practice.
9. Strengthen the relationship between school leaders and governors
Governors and trustees have an important role in providing strategic oversight, supporting school leaders and holding them to account for the quality of education and the use of resources.
Effective governance depends on having the right information and asking questions that help leaders evaluate progress.
Reports that contain large amounts of data but little explanation can make it difficult to identify the most important issues. Equally, broad assurances that a priority is “on track” may not provide enough information to understand whether meaningful improvement is taking place.
Governors should be able to explore:
- Why a particular priority has been selected.
- What evidence supports the school’s evaluation.
- What difference the actions are making for pupils.
- Whether progress is consistent across different groups.
- What barriers are preventing improvement.
- Whether resources are being used effectively.
- What leaders will do if the intended progress is not achieved.
The relationship should combine appropriate challenge with a shared commitment to improvement. Governors are not expected to manage the school day to day, but they should understand the key issues well enough to provide effective oversight.
In our experience, effective governance starts with having the right information to ask the right questions.
Review the information presented to governors at the next meeting. Does it clearly explain the school’s priorities, the evidence of progress, any barriers and the next steps? Identify where reports could be more focused and informative.
An external perspective can also help strengthen the quality of reporting and discussion. Jarvis Education’s Standard School Improvement Partner package includes regular visits, written feedback and ongoing advice to support school leaders and provide useful information for governors and trustees.
Our guide to the questions governors should ask about school improvement can help boards focus their challenge on the evidence and the difference being made for pupils.
10. Review progress regularly and be prepared to adapt
School improvement is not a straight line from identifying a problem to solving it. Some actions will produce the expected results. Others may take longer, reveal a different underlying issue or need to be changed.
The important thing is to build regular evaluation into the process so that leaders can respond to what they learn.
A review should consider more than whether agreed actions have been completed. It should explore whether those actions are having the intended effect. Our guide How Do You Know Whether Your School Improvement Plan Is Working? looks at the evidence to use.
For each priority, ask:
- What have we done since the last review?
- What evidence shows whether the work is making a difference?
- What has improved, and for whom?
- What remains a concern?
- Have any unexpected issues emerged?
- Do we need to change our approach or provide additional support?
- What are the most important next steps?
It is equally important to recognise progress. Improvement can become difficult to sustain if staff only hear about the problems that remain. Identifying what is working helps leaders understand which approaches are worth maintaining and sharing.
In our experience, school improvement is most effective when progress is reviewed regularly and actions are adapted where needed.
Schedule regular, focused reviews of your main improvement priorities. Record the evidence considered, the conclusions reached and any changes agreed. Make sure those decisions are revisited at the next review.
For schools facing significant change or needing closer support across several areas, the Comprehensive School Improvement Partner package offers a more intensive partnership, including six planned visits across the year, broader reviews and support for leaders and governors.
How do you decide which school improvement ideas to start with?
You do not need to introduce all ten ideas at once. In fact, trying to do so could create the very problem you are trying to solve: too many priorities competing for limited time and attention.
Start with an honest assessment of your school’s current position.
If your priorities are clear but you want an external perspective to validate your judgements, focused support may be enough. If you want regular input across the year, a more sustained partnership may be appropriate. If your school is navigating significant change or needs closer support across several areas, a comprehensive approach may be more suitable.
The right approach depends on your school’s context, capacity, challenges and ambitions.
A useful starting point is to ask:
- What is the most important issue we need to address?
- What evidence tells us this is the right priority?
- What would meaningful improvement look like for pupils?
- Do we have the capacity and expertise to lead the work ourselves?
- What support would help us make progress more effectively?
These questions help move school improvement away from simply generating more actions and towards making informed decisions about where effort will have the greatest value.
Final thoughts
Make school improvement purposeful, manageable and sustainable
Effective school improvement is not about doing more for the sake of it. It is about understanding your school, identifying what matters most and helping people work together to improve pupils’ experiences.
If you are considering external support, you may find it useful to read what happens during a School Improvement Partner visit.
That means being willing to question assumptions, listen to staff and pupils, use evidence carefully and adapt when something is not working as expected.
It also means recognising that school leaders do not have to work everything out alone. An experienced external partner can offer a fresh perspective, constructive challenge and practical support while keeping the responsibility and ownership of improvement within the school.
At Jarvis Education, we work with schools, trusts and education settings to help leaders understand their priorities and take practical steps towards improvement.
Would an independent perspective help your school move forward?
Explore Jarvis Education’s School Improvement Partner packages or get in touch with the team to discuss your school’s needs.
Jarvis Education. Helping schools become better schools.
Most relevant services
If this article reflects where your school is at the moment, these are the areas we most often support.
- Comprehensive School Improvement Partner Year-round school improvement support for schools, academies, trusts, and APs. Six visits a year,…
- Essentials School Improvement Partner Essentials school improvement partner for schools, academies, trusts and APs. Three focused visits and…
- Multi-Academy Trust Central Team Development Multi-academy trust central team development for schools, academies and trusts. Practical, independent support from…
- Bespoke INSET Day Training Bespoke INSET day training for schools and trusts. A tailored training day built around…
- Curriculum Impact Evaluation Independent curriculum impact evaluation for schools and trusts. Know whether pupils are really learning…
- Training & Professional Development Our training is built and delivered by experienced school leaders, inspectors, and subject specialists.
Continue exploring
More from our Knowledge Hub on the questions this article raises.
- School Improvement: Practical Guidance for School Leaders Practical guidance on understanding your setting, choosing the right priorities and checking that improvement work is…
- How to Write a School Improvement Plan That Leads to Real Change A school improvement plan should help leaders decide what needs to change, why it matters and…
- Why should a school have a school improvement partner? A school improvement partner is an experienced person who works alongside a school to help it…
- New Ofsted Framework Explained: What Changed and What It Means for Your School A complete guide to the new Ofsted framework, report cards, the five point grading scale and…
- How to Carry Out an Effective School Self-Evaluation How well do you really know your school? How to gather evidence, involve staff, pupils and…
- How Do You Know Whether Your School Improvement Plan Is Working? Completing actions is not the same as making a difference. How to use clear objectives, measurable…
School Improvement Guidance and Resources
Practical help with self-evaluation, choosing the right priorities and checking that improvement work is making a difference for pupils.
Let’s talk!
Hello, I’m Shaun.
Tell me what you need and I’ll come back to you personally.
