Headteacher Appraisal
Headteacher appraisal is one of the most important responsibilities a governing body or trust board holds. Done well, it strengthens leadership, drives…
Explore
A board is only as strong as the people on it. Finding governors and trustees with the right skills, and giving them a proper start, is one of the most valuable things a school or trust can invest in.
We help you recruit skilled, committed governors and trustees, and induct them well, so your board has the capability it needs.
Most boards recruit reactively, when someone resigns and a seat needs filling. The stronger approach is to know what you are missing before the vacancy appears, and to go looking for it.
It is support to recruit and induct governors and trustees. We help you identify the skills your board is missing, find and attract the right people, and give new members an induction that gets them contributing quickly and confidently.
The result is a board with genuine breadth of skill and new members who understand their role from the start.
It is for schools, governing bodies, and trusts wanting to strengthen their board, fill vacancies, or improve how they bring new members on. It suits boards that recognise skills gaps and want to close them deliberately rather than by chance.
This is the first thing that confuses new volunteers, and quite a few experienced ones.
In a maintained school, governors sit on the governing board. They set strategic direction, hold the headteacher to account, and oversee financial performance. The categories are set out in regulations and usually include parent, staff, local authority, and co-opted governors, alongside the headteacher.
In an academy trust, the picture has more layers. Members sit above the board and have a small but important set of powers, including appointing trustees and amending the articles of association. Trustees are the directors of the company and the charity trustees, and they carry legal responsibility for the trust. Local governors sit on local governing bodies, and what they can decide depends entirely on the trust’s scheme of delegation.
That last point causes more difficulty than any other. A local governor who believes they are holding a school to account, when their body is in fact advisory, will be frustrated within a term. Being honest about the role at the point of recruitment prevents that.
We often see trusts recruit enthusiastic local governors and then lose them, not because the people were wrong but because nobody explained clearly what the role actually was.
Boards tend to recruit in their own image. The people you know are the people you ask, and over time that produces a board with a lot of one thing and very little of another.
A skills audit gives you an honest map. It shows what expertise you hold, where you are thin, where you are relying on a single person, and what will be missing when a long-standing member steps down next year.
It also changes the recruitment conversation. Asking for a governor is vague. Asking for someone with capital projects experience who can give a few hours a term is specific, and specific asks attract better candidates.
Boards often assume the pool is small. In our experience it is larger than expected and simply badly advertised.
The obvious routes are parent elections and staff elections, which fill particular seats but cannot be relied on for specific skills. Beyond those, there are national volunteer matching services that connect professionals with boards, local employers with community engagement schemes, professional bodies in finance, law, and property, universities and alumni networks, and the local business community.
The most underused route is your own network of former parents and former staff. People who know the school, have time now that their children have moved on, and are often waiting to be asked.
What makes the difference is the ask itself. A clear role description, an honest account of the time involved, and a specific explanation of why this board needs this person will outperform a general appeal every time.
This is where boards most often trip up, and where an Ofsted inspection or a single central record audit tends to find the gap.
An enhanced DBS check is required for governors, trustees, and local governors. Governance itself is not regulated activity, so a barred list check is not usually needed unless the individual also engages in regulated activity in the school.
A section 128 check is also required. A section 128 direction prohibits someone from taking part in the management of an academy, free school, or independent school, and a person subject to one is also disqualified from holding office as a governor of a maintained school. This applies across school types, and it extends to trust members, trustees, and local governors on bodies with delegated responsibilities.
Eligibility and disqualification criteria must be checked as well. For maintained schools these are set out in regulations. For trusts they sit in the articles of association, alongside the automatic disqualification rules that apply to charity trustees.
Trustees are also company directors, which brings Companies House obligations, including identity verification requirements introduced under recent economic crime legislation. New trustees are sometimes surprised by this, so it is better raised at recruitment than discovered afterwards.
We help boards get all of this right first time, and record it properly, so that a new appointment does not turn into a compliance finding six months later.
An induction is not a welcome email and a link to the last set of minutes. Done properly, it is the difference between a governor who contributes in their first term and one who spends a year working out what is going on.
A strong induction covers the role and its legal duties, the difference between governance and management, the school or trust’s structure and scheme of delegation, the current improvement priorities, how the budget works and what the board is accountable for financially, safeguarding responsibilities including governor-specific training, the code of conduct, and the practical mechanics of meetings, papers, and confidentiality.
It should also include the things nobody writes down. Who is who. What the board has already decided and why. Which questions have been asked recently. Where the tensions are.
Keeping Children Safe in Education expects governors and trustees to receive safeguarding and child protection training at induction, updated regularly. Boards that treat this as a tick box tend to have members who nod along in safeguarding discussions rather than probing them.
Recruitment gets the attention. Retention is usually the bigger problem.
The reasons people step down are consistent. They could not see what difference they were making. The papers were impenetrable. Meetings ran long and decided little. They never received an induction and were too embarrassed to admit how lost they felt. Or they were recruited for a role that turned out to be advisory when they thought it was accountable.
Every one of those is within the board’s control. Boards that induct well, use people’s skills deliberately, and give new members something specific to own tend to keep them.
We build retention into the recruitment work rather than treating it as a separate problem, because a board that loses two governors a year is always recruiting and never strengthening.
The chair, the vice chair, the chair of the finance or audit committee, and the safeguarding link governor are the roles that carry a board. Losing any of them without a plan creates real disruption.
Good succession planning identifies potential future chairs early, gives them experience of leading a committee, and makes the expectations of the role explicit rather than mysterious. It also avoids the common outcome where a long-serving chair stays on well past the point they intended, because nobody else feels ready.
We help boards think several years ahead, so leadership on the board is planned rather than improvised.
Trust-level inspection has been placed on a statutory footing, with the Department for Education indicating a focus on leadership, governance, and impact. The framework is still being developed and inspections are not expected before the 2027 to 2028 academic year.
There is no need to react to a framework nobody has seen. But the direction is clear, and the boards that will find it comfortable are those that can show a deliberate approach to who sits on the board, why they were recruited, and how they were prepared for the role.
A skills audit, a proper induction, and clean records of appointment and checks are useful whatever the framework turns out to say.
Boards often recruit whoever is available. We help you identify the skills you actually lack and recruit deliberately to fill them.
Good candidates need a compelling, clear ask. We help you describe the role in a way that draws capable, committed volunteers.
A board that reflects its community governs better. We help you widen your reach beyond the usual networks.
A strong induction turns a willing volunteer into a contributing governor fast. We give new members the grounding they need.
Skilled, well-inducted governors ask better questions and give better challenge. That lifts the quality of everything the board does.
Governors who feel lost tend to leave. A proper induction keeps good people engaged and on the board.
Eligibility, DBS, and section 128 checks are easily missed at appointment. We make sure they are done and recorded properly.
People stay when the role matches what they were told. We help you describe it accurately, including what the board can and cannot decide.
We help you plan ahead for chairs and key roles, so leadership on the board is never left to chance.
We start from what your board actually needs, not just filling seats.
New members get a real grounding, so they contribute quickly and stay.
Our support comes from people who understand boards from the inside.
Governors sit on the governing board of a maintained school. Trustees are the directors and charity trustees of an academy trust, carrying legal responsibility for the trust and everything within it. Local governors in a trust sit on local governing bodies and hold whatever responsibilities the trust’s scheme of delegation gives them, which varies considerably between trusts.
Members sit above the trust board. Their powers are limited but significant, and typically include appointing and removing trustees and amending the articles of association. They are sometimes described as the guardians of the trust’s governance. The role is deliberately separate from the board so that members can hold trustees to account.
Yes. An enhanced DBS check is required for governors, trustees, and local governors. Because governance is not regulated activity, a barred list check is not normally required unless the individual is also involved in regulated activity in the school.
Yes, across all school types. A section 128 direction prohibits someone from taking part in the management of an academy, free school, or independent school, and also disqualifies them from serving as a governor of a maintained school. The check extends to trust members, trustees, and local governors on bodies with delegated responsibilities. It is one of the most commonly missed entries on a single central record.
Disqualification criteria are set out in regulations for maintained schools, and in the articles of association together with charity law for trusts. They cover matters including bankruptcy, certain criminal convictions, disqualification from acting as a company director, and being subject to a section 128 direction. Anyone recruiting to a board should check eligibility before appointment rather than after.
Four years is the usual term for maintained school governors, and trust articles commonly set a similar period for trustees. Terms can be renewed. Boards that track terms of office carefully avoid the awkward situation of discovering that several members’ terms expired some months ago.
No. Governance is a voluntary role. Reasonable expenses can be reimbursed, and boards that pay expenses properly tend to recruit more widely, because the cost of travel and childcare is a genuine barrier for some excellent candidates.
It varies with the board and the role, but most governors should expect a full board meeting each term, committee meetings, reading time for papers, occasional school visits, and training. Chairs and committee chairs commit considerably more. Being honest about this at recruitment is far better than understating it and losing someone in their first year.
An induction covering the role, the legal duties, the structure of the school or trust, finance, and accountability, plus governor-specific safeguarding and child protection training, which Keeping Children Safe in Education expects at induction and regularly thereafter. Ongoing training should follow the gaps identified in your skills audit.
By asking specifically, and by going where those people are. Professional bodies, local accountancy and finance networks, and national volunteer matching services all work far better than a general appeal on the school newsletter. A precise ask, with a clear description of what the role involves, is what converts interest into applications.
Yes, and most boards should. Co-opted and appointed places exist precisely so that boards can bring in skills the parent and staff body may not hold. A board made up entirely of current parents can find it harder to take a long view.
This is a common request, and it works best when the trust is clear from the outset about what the local governing body will actually decide. We help trusts describe the role honestly, recruit into it, and induct new local governors into the trust’s way of working.
We work only in education and understand what makes a board genuinely effective. Our support helps you recruit for the skills you need and induct new members properly, so your governance is stronger, better informed, and more confident in holding the school or trust to account.
Our consultants have sat on boards, worked with them, and seen what separates a board that challenges well from one that simply receives reports. That perspective shapes how we recruit and how we induct.
And the purpose behind all of it is simple. Boards make decisions that shape what children experience every day. Getting the right people around the table, properly prepared, is one of the most direct ways to improve those decisions.
We support settings of every type across England and internationally.
We are only a message away. Contact us today and find out how we could help your school or trust to excel.
Leave your details and Shaun, our Founder and CEO, will get back to you. No pressure, no obligation, just a friendly chat.
Just a few details and Shaun will be in touch.
Headteacher appraisal is one of the most important responsibilities a governing body or trust board holds. Done well, it strengthens leadership, drives…
ExploreWhen governance fails, fractures, or simply cannot meet the moment, schools and trusts need rapid, expert intervention to restore stability and drive…
ExploreThe most important strategic decision any board ever makes is who leads the school or trust. The wrong appointment can cost years…
ExploreWe use cookies to run our website, understand how it's used and improve your experience. You can accept all cookies, reject non-essential ones, or set your preferences. Read our Cookie Policy.
Required for the website to function, including remembering your cookie choices. These cannot be switched off.
Help us understand how the site is used, so we can measure and improve it. Collected anonymously through Google Analytics.